The murder investigation that disrupts the very soul of Crittenden County's Amish community comes to a close. Deborah tries to move forward after the tragic death of her brother Perry, by taking a job with the local store that Jacob's family owns. As Jacob and Deborah start a fledgling courtship, the news is revealed that Jacob was in a fist fight with Perry the night he died; crushing Deborah's spirit and trust. Can she possibly trust her heart enough to believe that Jacob didn't do it...and if not, will the real killer reveal himself?
