Promise Lodge colony begins with three Amish sister who want to put misfortune behind them. Mattie Bender Schwartz is working hard to get the lodge up and running. Her son Noah is healing after a broken engagement. His former fiancée Deborah regrets the breakup. She shows up at the Promise Lodge to apologize. Noah is hesitant to accept the apology. With the help of his mother, aunts and preacher, he may finally forgive.