Beverly Overholt grew up Amish and is now Mennonite. When the Orange Blossom Inn is robbed, she is understandably shaken. The Inn has been her life. She notifies Eric Wagler, the handsome owner, who rushes in from Philadelphia ready to help. She has her guard up after a her previous engagement gone bad. Eric works on breaking down that wall. After their rocky start as surprise business partners, will Eric finally make Beverly his Christmas bride?