Julia Padden is friendly and bubbly. She likes almost everyone except for her standoffish neighbor Cain Maddox. She has tried to be nice on several occasions but he is rude in return every time. After she catches him stealing her newspaper from the lobby of their apartment building, she decides to kill him with kindness and tracks her progress by starting an online blog called The Twelve Days of Christmas. Julia brings him homemade Christmas treats and the grinch won't accept them. Her blog becomes and online sensation. Little by little she chips away at his gruff facade to find a caring man underneath. As they start to fall for each other, should she be honest with him about her chronicling their relationship to the rest of the world so they have a chance at love?