The Kinsinger siblings are struggling to find forgiveness and love due to a tragedy. Everything changed when Darla Kurtz's father was found responsible for a terrible fire, which killed him along with four other Amish men, at the town’s lumber mill. Now, the town people looked at her family differently, including Lukas Kinsinger, who Darla had always been close friends with. Her brother's anger at the town is starting to infect Darla. Lukas Kinsinger wants to mourn the loss of his father, lumber mill wants him to take his father's place and he is responsible for taking care of his three siblings. As Lukas and Darla attempt to repair their families, they discover something deeper than friendship growing between them. Will the town people change their opinion of Darla's family so the two can enjoy a happy future together?