Amelia Kinsinger is an Amish woman who appears perfect in her neighbors eyes. Simon Hochstetler had run away from an abusive home at the age of fifteen and ended up in prison. The experience changed him. He tries not to think of his past unless it has to do with Amelia. She feels the same way about him. Her older brother Lukas is Simon's best friend. He has made it clear that Amelia deserves better. Simon believes he is the only one who can make her truly happy. After Amelia gets hurt, they consider their future together. Will they trust each other with the secrets of their past?