Levi Kinsinger returns to his old life in Charm, Ohio after a tragic fire kills his father. He finds he does not fit in. Julia Kemps is his neighbor, who has recently moved to Charm. She has told everyone she is a widow so they will accept her, since she is an Amish single mother. Levi finally feels a sense of purpose by helping her with a Christmas Project, but he can tell Julia is hiding something. As she begins to dream of a future with him, she imagines telling him her secret. Will the two be able to face their pasts to find healing and move on to a possible future together?