Grandma Lapp had wanted to start an Amish pony farm. She purchased three Assateague ponies just before she died. Now it is up to her granddaughter Phoebe to fulfill her dream. Phoebe is also offered a teaching position. Grandma had recruited the neighbor David Fisher to help run the farm. David has a crush on Phoebe. Should Phoebe live out her teaching dream or her grandmother's life long dream?